The Pros and Cons of Adapting a Classic
So You Want to Adapt a Classic? Considering the benefits of adapting the classics of literature—the proven success of their themes and structure, iconic lines, enduring timeliness, and strong characters—the question is, why WOULDN’T you want to adapt a classic? Because it’s already been done. To DEATH , you answer. Take Sherlock Holmes. Adaptations are endless, with new ones nearly every year. And the approaches writers take encompass a wide range: placing him in modern times, as a comedic figure, as a young man, as an old man, with dark secrets Doyle never would have imagined, and with Watson as a woman. There’s even the thinly veiled homage of Gregory House, brilliantly played by Hugh Laurie, which I’ll explore more later. So, I understand your concerns… in everything I write, in whatever genre, from historical fiction to adapting true stories [ https://joeymadiastoryteller.blogspot.com/2025/02/why-based-on-true-story-is-barely-based.html ] and classics for young audiences a...